
Enjoy fast, free delivery, exclusive deals, and award-winning movies & TV shows with Prime
Try Prime
and start saving today with fast, free delivery
Amazon Prime includes:
Fast, FREE Delivery is available to Prime members. To join, select "Try Amazon Prime and start saving today with Fast, FREE Delivery" below the Add to Cart button.
Amazon Prime members enjoy:- Cardmembers earn 5% Back at Amazon.com with a Prime Credit Card.
- Unlimited Free Two-Day Delivery
- Streaming of thousands of movies and TV shows with limited ads on Prime Video.
- A Kindle book to borrow for free each month - with no due dates
- Listen to over 2 million songs and hundreds of playlists
- Unlimited photo storage with anywhere access
Important: Your credit card will NOT be charged when you start your free trial or if you cancel during the trial period. If you're happy with Amazon Prime, do nothing. At the end of the free trial, your membership will automatically upgrade to a monthly membership.
Brizled Orange & Purple Halloween Lights, 2 Pack Total 78ft 240 LED Orange Lights, Purple Solar Halloween Lights 8 Modes, Outdoor Twinkle Orange Halloween String Lights Black Wire for Halloween Decor
Return this item for free
We offer easy, convenient returns with at least one free return option: no shipping charges. All returns must comply with our returns policy.
Learn more about free returns.- Go to your orders and start the return
- Select your preferred free shipping option
- Drop off and leave!
Purchase options and add-ons
Color | Purple & Orange |
Brand | Brizled |
Indoor/Outdoor Usage | Outdoor |
Special Feature | Twinkling, Waterproof |
Light Source Type | LED |
Power Source | Solar Powered |
Light Color | Orange & Purple |
Theme | Halloween |
Occasion | Halloween |
Style | Modern |
About this item
- Solar Orange & Purple Lights Halloween: Updated larger absorbed area solar panel with built-in Ni-MH AA battery, features higher solar energy conversion efficiency, enable to keep these black wire fairy lights working up to 10-12 hours after fully charged. 39.37ft long per strand with 120 LED orange & purple light beads, emitting a spooky glow, create a horror and mysterious atmosphere for Halloween.
- Auto On/Off Outdoor Halloween Lights LED: Please Keep the power switch in "ON" position. Built-in light sensor, these led orange & purple lights will be auto on at night, auto-off and charging during the daytime. solar powered Halloween lights string, no battery or electricity required, charged by the sunlight, can work up to 12 hours when fully charged. Adopted low heat led beads, low consumption, eco-friendly.
- 8 Modes & Memory Function Orange & Purple Fairy Lights: Our purple & orange Halloween lights string have 8 lighting modes including combination, fireflies flashing, waves, fading, chasing/flashing, fading slowly, twinkle/flashing and steady on, select the right mode to lit solid orange & purple light or twinkle for Halloween party. Built-in memory function, remember last setting automatically after turn off, no need to reset every day!
- Bendable Black Wire Halloween Lights: These led solar Halloween lights adopted flexible black copper wire, moldable and durable enough to be properly twisted and shaped to the patterns you desired, for example, boo letter or ghost shape etc for the coming Halloween! Or they can be easily wrapped around plants, tree trunks, furniture Halloween tree and almost everything else, it is a great fun to have DIY with your kids!
- Widely Indoor Outdoor Decorative Halloween Lights: Both the entire lights and the solar panel are waterproof, can withstand all kinds of weather. Our solar lights glow in orange & purple are perfect for decorating and illuminating entrance, garden, yard, fireplace, haunted house etc. to create a spooky ambiance, suitable for indoor and outdoor Halloween lighting.
Frequently bought together

Frequently purchased items with fast delivery
From the brand

Various Christmas Lights
Emitting vivid glowing, create cozy and romantic atmospheres and make your Christmas decorations outstanding from your neighbors.
-
Smart Christmas Lights
-
RGB Christmas Lights
-
Color Changing String Lights
-
Christmas Tree Top with Lights
-
Solar Outdoor Lights
-
UL Listed C9 Christmas Lights
-
Green Wire Xmas Lights
-
C5 Xmas Lights
-
Outdoor Christmas lights
-
APP Controlled Xmas lights
Videos
Videos for this product
1:28
Click to play video
Honest Review- Fairy String Lights, Indoor outdoor -Solar
Virginia Grant
Videos for this product
0:55
Click to play video
Customer Review: Super cool lights but to fine wires =TANGLED
Susan
Product Description

Solar Power Orange & Purple Lights, Halloween ambiance creator, added solar-powered feature with upgraded solar panel that enables up to 10-12 working hours after fully charged, no trouble of buying battery frequently, our led purple & orange solar lights are energy and money saving Halloween lights, a good choice for Halloween decoration!



Specifications:
- Powered: Solar Powered
- Lights Color: Orange & Purple
- Wire Color: Black Wire
- LED Quantity: 120 LED Per Strand(Total 240 LED)
- Bulb Space: 0.33ft
- Lead Length: 6.56ft
- Lighted Length: 39.37ft(2 pcs total 78.74ft)
- Total Length: 45.93ft(2 pcs total 91.86ft)
Solar Orange & Purple Halloween String Lights
Features:
Solar-powered Halloween lights, adopted low heat led beads, and low consumption.
Built-in light sensor, lights will auto on at night and auto off at day.
Flexible Black Wire Halloween Lights, malleable and durable to use. Waterproof design, suitable for outdoor use!
Package Included:
2 x 120 LED Solar String Lights
2 x Solar Panel with Ground Stake
1 x User Manual
Auto On/Off, Operational Friendly Orange & Purple Lights String
Built-in light sensor, these led Halloween lights will be auto-on at night, auto-off and charging during the daytime, no need to turn them on/off manually, hands-free operation, and no more energy waste during daytime.
Sturdy Flexible Black Wire and Waterproof Fairy Lights for Halloween
Thin but sturdy enough black coated silver wire, can be bent into any shape you want or easily wrapped around a tree, pattern, etc, to get a lighted Halloween spider, a ghost for example. Both the entire lights and the solar panel are waterproof and can withstand all kinds of weather.
8 Modes Mini Orange & Purple lights
There are solid On mode and many twinkle/flash modes available, our led purple & orange string lights are ideal for daily Halloween decor or crazy Halloween parties! Get them to light up your room, house, garden, trick-or-treat entrance, tree, and so on, your Halloween decoration will outstanding from your neighbors!

![]()
Battery Pumkin Lights
|
![]()
2 Pack Each 19.47ft 60 LED Orange Lights
|
![]()
216 LED 18ft Orange & Purple Rope Lights
|
![]()
72.17ft 200 LED Purple & Orange Halloween Lights
|
![]()
2 Pack Each 19.47ft 60 LED Purple & Orange Halloween Lights
|
![]()
12 Pack Each 20 LED Purple & Orange Fairy Lights
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Add to Cart
|
Add to Cart
|
Add to Cart
|
||||
Customer Reviews |
4.3 out of 5 stars 573
|
4.4 out of 5 stars 1,148
|
4.4 out of 5 stars 3,961
|
4.3 out of 5 stars 581
|
4.4 out of 5 stars 145
|
4.5 out of 5 stars 1,259
|
Price | $9.99$9.99 | $9.99$9.99 | — no data | — no data | — no data | $11.99$11.99 |
Lighted Length | 13.12ft | Each 19.47ft(2 Pack Total 38.94ft) | 18ft | 72.17ft | Each 19.47ft(2 Pack Total 38.94ft) | Each 6.56ft(12 Pack Total 78.72ft) |
Power Source | Battery Operated | Battery Operated | plug in | plug in | Battery Operated | Battery Operated |
Light Source | LED | LED | LED | LED | LED | LED |
Connectable | No | No | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Lights Quantity | 40 LED | Each 60 LED(2 Pack Total 120 LED) | 216 LED | 200 LED | Each 60 LED(2 Pack Total 120 LED) | Each 20 LED(12 Pack Total 240 LED) |
Lighting Modes | 8 Lighting Modes | 2 Lighting Modes | Steady On | 8 Lighting Modes | 2 Lighting Modes | Steady On |
Memory Function | Yes | No | no data | Yes | No | no data |
Looking for specific info?
Product information
Color | Purple & Orange |
---|---|
Brand | Brizled |
Indoor/Outdoor Usage | Outdoor |
Special Feature | Twinkling, Waterproof |
Light Source Type | LED |
Power Source | Solar Powered |
Light Color | Orange & Purple |
Theme | Halloween |
Occasion | Halloween |
Style | Modern |
Material | Copper |
Controller Type | Button Control |
Number of Light Sources | 120 |
Voltage | 1.2 Volts |
Included Components | 2 x 120 LED Solar String Lights, 2 x Solar Panel with Ground Stake |
Item Weight | 8.47 ounces |
Number of Items | 2 |
Control Method | Touch |
Water Resistance Level | Waterproof |
Seasons | autumn |
Package Dimensions | 6.73 x 5.51 x 0.85 inches |
Item Weight | 8.5 ounces |
ASIN | B09QHYWS6X |
Customer Reviews |
4.2 out of 5 stars |
Best Sellers Rank | #19,087 in Tools & Home Improvement (See Top 100 in Tools & Home Improvement) #194 in Outdoor String Lights |
Warranty & Support
Feedback

Brizled Orange & Purple Halloween Lights, 2 Pack Total 78ft 240 LED Orange Lights, Purple Solar Halloween Lights 8 Modes, Outdoor Twinkle Orange Halloween String Lights Black Wire for Halloween Decor
Share:
Found a lower price? Let us know. Although we can't match every price reported, we'll use your feedback to ensure that our prices remain competitive.
Where did you see a lower price?
Fields with an asterisk * are required
Compare with similar items
This Item ![]() Brizled Orange & Purple Halloween Lights, 2 Pack Total 78ft 240 LED Orange Lights, Purple Solar Halloween Lights 8 Modes, Outdoor Twinkle Orange Halloween String Lights Black Wire for Halloween Decor | Recommendations | |||||
Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | Try again! Added to Cart Add to cart | |
Price | $15.99$15.99 | $25.99$25.99 | $24.99$24.99 | $12.99$12.99 | $25.99$25.99 | $12.99$12.99 |
Delivery | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 | Get it as soon as Friday, Mar 21 |
Customer Ratings | ||||||
Sold By | SmartWiz Brands | Joomer Direct | Flacchi | Junji Ya | Zhenyu-US | YiYuan LLC |
size | 2 Pack | 200LED*2 | 2 Pack | 2 Pack | 4 Pack | 2 Pack |
light source type | LED | LED | LED | LED | LED | LED |
power source | Solar Powered | Solar Powered | Solar Powered | Solar Powered | Solar Powered | Solar Powered |
light sources | 120 | 200 | 200 | 120 | 320 | 120 |
control method | touch | touch | touch | touch | touch | touch |
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers appreciate the string lights' brightness and appearance. They find the lights bright and impressive at night, providing a pleasant ambiance. The lights are colorful and look great, complementing Halloween decorations. Many customers find the installation process easy. However, some customers report issues with the copper wire tangles easily, making it difficult to untangle. Opinions vary on functionality, value for money, durability, and nighttime performance.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers appreciate the string lights' brightness and twinkle. They say the lights last a long time and provide enough twinkle to make their outdoors not look dull. The ambient lighting is spectacular, and the lights are light sensitive so they turn off when it's dark. Many consider these one of the better solar lights they've purchased. The string lights wind around the solar collector for easy no-mess storage, and customers love the features for changing the lighting patterns.
"...The light is pleasant, bright, and long lasting...." Read more
"...The lights aren't over powerfully bright, and the small lights lay flat against the rail so they don't get snagged on anything...." Read more
"...this product to anyone seeking an attractive and affordable lighting solution. Its versatility and ease of use make it a worthwhile purchase." Read more
"...But these are tiny little lights, not big Christmas style ones...." Read more
Customers like the lights' appearance. They find them pretty and enchanting, with colorful lighting modes that create a delightful ambiance. The lights are brighter than expected and provide a pleasant lighting experience. Many consider the lights an adorable new landscaping toy and a good decoration for outside during Halloween or just wanting lights outside their house. The lights come in purple and orange colors, with patterns or solid light options.
"...They're more colorful and brighter than I expected too...." Read more
"...both a tree and a fence, and the eight lighting modes provide a delightful ambiance. The product also offers exceptional value for money...." Read more
"...It looks great for the one that works and lasts long enough to have a good review...." Read more
"...Colored lights are much prettier than any solar powered lights I could find at local retailers. Highly recommend." Read more
Customers find the string lights easy to install and use. The wire bends easily, making installation on rigid surfaces relatively simple. They like the simple on/off feature and the ability to adjust the pattern. Overall, customers find the product straightforward and inexpensive.
"...compact, the copper wire bends easily to make installation on rigid surfaces comparatively easy. The light is pleasant, bright, and long lasting...." Read more
"...Its versatility and ease of use make it a worthwhile purchase." Read more
"...Kind of a pain to unwind and set up but I think worth it. When new, can last until morn but fades as they get older...." Read more
"Straight forward product! Got it fairly cheap and used it all october...." Read more
Customers have different views on the string lights' functionality. Some find them useful and effective, with no issues or complaints. Others report that one day after receiving the lights, they stopped working altogether or only half of the lights worked.
"...Some not all of the lights will work. They last only a few hours at best. They are a great concept but they did not work they way I had hoped...." Read more
"Overall, I'm highly impressed with this product. It functions flawlessly, living up to its advertised capabilities...." Read more
"After 2 weeks of owning these, one of the lights no longer works. They are super nice just don't expect to have these for long." Read more
"The one sting of lights worked great, however the second string only worked halfway down the string, one side of the wiring is broken, so only half..." Read more
Customers have mixed opinions about the value for money of the string lights. Some find them well worth the cost and appreciate that they work without having to pay for electricity. Others feel the lights are a waste of money and not worth the hassle and savings of going solar.
"...The product also offers exceptional value for money. The only reason I'm giving it four stars is due to the thinness of the copper string...." Read more
"Since the price was good, I didn’t have high hopes for long life on these but am pleasantly surprised!..." Read more
"...looks like a stable spool of lights when in reality they are considerably less...." Read more
"Straight forward product! Got it fairly cheap and used it all october...." Read more
Customers have mixed opinions about the string lights' durability. Some are satisfied with their longevity, saying they hold up through hurricane seasons and harsh winters without wear. Others mention fragile wiring that breaks easily, bends easily, and keeps tangling.
"...a tangled mess that one must carefully work through as the wires are a little fragile. So, plan your run ahead and start at the end of your run." Read more
"...This band beat the other in length by double, also beat it in durability. They both appear as bright as each other in a side by side comparison...." Read more
"...the second string only worked halfway down the string, one side of the wiring is broken, so only half of the string works...." Read more
"Straight forward product! Got it fairly cheap and used it all october...." Read more
Customers have different experiences with the string lights. Some say they stay lit for hours into the night, turning on every night without fail. Others mention the lights only last for 3 hours each evening, barely charge, and don't last long.
"...The battery is great! They turn on at dusk, and are still on in the morning when I get up. They're more colorful and brighter than I expected too...." Read more
"...Charges up quickly on sunny days and last until late into the night...." Read more
"...But over the last week they barely charge and the light does not last long. If you live in the PNW then I would choose a different brand." Read more
"...were simple to put up and take down, looked great and stayed charge all night...." Read more
Customers find the string lights difficult to untangle. They mention the copper wires get tangled easily, and it's difficult to unravel the string.
"...Cons: the copper wire does tangle with itself quite easily. It comes on a plastic spool wound such that you have to start with the unpowered end...." Read more
"...Re-wrapping it is equally challenging, and I've opted to leave it permanently affixed to the tree...." Read more
"...They are literally knotted together at different intervals throughout the wrapping, so you’re required to go through the laborious task of unwinding..." Read more
"...untangle it, it's springlike action causes it to retract and get tangled in new ways...." Read more
Reviews with images

Great
Top reviews from the United States
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United States on December 11, 2024Color: MulticolorVerified PurchasePros: very compact, the copper wire bends easily to make installation on rigid surfaces comparatively easy. The light is pleasant, bright, and long lasting. The available modes selections were easy to use, and varied enough that we found one that made us both happy.
Cons: the copper wire does tangle with itself quite easily. It comes on a plastic spool wound such that you have to start with the unpowered end. I recommend against unspooling it so you can start with the powered end; that creates a tangled mess that one must carefully work through as the wires are a little fragile. So, plan your run ahead and start at the end of your run.
- Reviewed in the United States on October 10, 2024Color: Purple & OrangeVerified PurchaseThese little lights work a lot better than I expected! I put them on my front porch for Halloween, wrapping around the top railing. I secured in place with a zip tie on the starting end, and then used another tie to hold the solar charger on the railing bannister facing the sun direction. The battery is great! They turn on at dusk, and are still on in the morning when I get up. They're more colorful and brighter than I expected too. The lights aren't over powerfully bright, and the small lights lay flat against the rail so they don't get snagged on anything. Would definitely buy again!
5.0 out of 5 starsThese little lights work a lot better than I expected! I put them on my front porch for Halloween, wrapping around the top railing. I secured in place with a zip tie on the starting end, and then used another tie to hold the solar charger on the railing bannister facing the sun direction. The battery is great! They turn on at dusk, and are still on in the morning when I get up. They're more colorful and brighter than I expected too. The lights aren't over powerfully bright, and the small lights lay flat against the rail so they don't get snagged on anything. Would definitely buy again!Lights up all night long!
Reviewed in the United States on October 10, 2024
Images in this review
- Reviewed in the United States on November 19, 2023Color: MulticolorVerified PurchaseOverall, I'm highly impressed with this product. It functions flawlessly, living up to its advertised capabilities. I've used it to illuminate both a tree and a fence, and the eight lighting modes provide a delightful ambiance. The product also offers exceptional value for money.
The only reason I'm giving it four stars is due to the thinness of the copper string. Unwinding it proves to be a patience-testing endeavor, as a slight misstep can result in a tangled mess. Re-wrapping it is equally challenging, and I've opted to leave it permanently affixed to the tree.
Despite this minor drawback, I wholeheartedly recommend this product to anyone seeking an attractive and affordable lighting solution. Its versatility and ease of use make it a worthwhile purchase.
- Reviewed in the United States on February 6, 2025Color: Warm WhiteVerified PurchaseSince the price was good, I didn’t have high hopes for long life on these but am pleasantly surprised! I’ve had them hanging outside 24/7/365 for almost 3 whole years in all weather and they still work! (I’m in an all-seasons area, with snow and single digit temps in winter and humidity and 90s + in the summer). I’m constantly surprised they’re still functioning. A great value for the price.
- Reviewed in the United States on November 17, 2024Color: PurpleVerified PurchaseThe media could not be loaded.
5.0 out of 5 starsSo I had first got one brand last year and wasn't happy with it, after getting the purple ones for halloween, i was pleasantly surprised that I tried the warm white for Christmas. The photos and video are side by side comparison. This band beat the other in length by double, also beat it in durability. They both appear as bright as each other in a side by side comparison. I remembered the purple being much brighter then the warm white ones are for some reason but it still works. Saves you on the electric bill and the Reed to run extention cords far out away from the house.Works great and better when compared to others.
Reviewed in the United States on November 17, 2024
Images in this review
- Reviewed in the United States on December 11, 2020Color: MulticolorVerified PurchaseDon’t buy these. I don’t typically leave reviews, but these needed it. I know you get what you pay for but these, feel like they’re purposely tied to be difficult for the customer. I purchased them for a little surprise decorating to cheer up my fiancé who could use a little Christmas cheer (couldn’t we all this year!), but I wasn’t expecting such an awful experience. I’ve worked with a a lot of string lights before traditional and fairy style (like these), and I’ve NEVER had this style issue before. They are literally knotted together at different intervals throughout the wrapping, so you’re required to go through the laborious task of unwinding, un- knotting, and untwisting then before you put them up. At first I thought it was because I had accidentally made the cardinal sin of trying to unwind them first, so I thought I might have inadvertently made a knot. So I tried attaching and unrolling the on my deck with the second set, only to find the knots and realize that you can’t do that, because you must remove the knots at each interval, to fully unwind the lights and be able twist them around your desired space. Which is dangerous considering wire based fairy lights are temperamental to begin with and can easily break when I improperly bent. Which is what happened here. They worked just fine before I unwinded them, and at the half way check during. But as soon as I was done, they no longer worked (which was essentially unavoidable considering how they were tied/knotted). So now I’m devastated I can’t do this surprise. I would like a refund (and the last hour+ of my time back), but I highly doubt anyone will take this seriously. So I thought my review might help people from making the same mistake. I also took a pic so you can see the style of unavoidable knots throughout.
Don’t buy these. I don’t typically leave reviews, but these needed it. I know you get what you pay for but these, feel like they’re purposely tied to be difficult for the customer. I purchased them for a little surprise decorating to cheer up my fiancé who could use a little Christmas cheer (couldn’t we all this year!), but I wasn’t expecting such an awful experience. I’ve worked with a a lot of string lights before traditional and fairy style (like these), and I’ve NEVER had this style issue before. They are literally knotted together at different intervals throughout the wrapping, so you’re required to go through the laborious task of unwinding, un- knotting, and untwisting then before you put them up. At first I thought it was because I had accidentally made the cardinal sin of trying to unwind them first, so I thought I might have inadvertently made a knot. So I tried attaching and unrolling the on my deck with the second set, only to find the knots and realize that you can’t do that, because you must remove the knots at each interval, to fully unwind the lights and be able twist them around your desired space. Which is dangerous considering wire based fairy lights are temperamental to begin with and can easily break when I improperly bent. Which is what happened here. They worked just fine before I unwinded them, and at the half way check during. But as soon as I was done, they no longer worked (which was essentially unavoidable considering how they were tied/knotted). So now I’m devastated I can’t do this surprise. I would like a refund (and the last hour+ of my time back), but I highly doubt anyone will take this seriously. So I thought my review might help people from making the same mistake. I also took a pic so you can see the style of unavoidable knots throughout.
Images in this review
- Reviewed in the United States on October 22, 2023Color: PurpleVerified PurchaseThe one sting of lights worked great, however the second string only worked halfway down the string, one side of the wiring is broken, so only half of the string works. It looks great for the one that works and lasts long enough to have a good review. The bad is they are wound to tight and this causes then to be broken in transit or when packed, also causes problems when unwinding them to put them up.
- Reviewed in the United States on October 6, 2024Color: MulticolorVerified PurchaseI love the look of a lit up patio and back yard, but plug in lights are very expensive to run. These solar powered lights can be wrapped around trees or placed around borders to light up your outdoor space and making it beautiful and safe. Charges up quickly on sunny days and last until late into the night. Colored lights are much prettier than any solar powered lights I could find at local retailers. Highly recommend.
Top reviews from other countries
- Kerri V.Reviewed in Canada on June 24, 2024
5.0 out of 5 stars Nice colors
Color: Purple & OrangeVerified PurchaseLights look fantastic
- DarleneReviewed in Canada on December 11, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars love lights
Color: PurpleVerified Purchaselights up way into the night.love it
-
Yaraset L.Reviewed in Mexico on October 31, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars Super Padres :)
Color: PurpleVerified Purchaseme encantaron me sorprendieron por el costo :)
-
Marco Antonio Martinez DomniguezReviewed in Mexico on October 4, 2023
5.0 out of 5 stars Muy buenas
Color: Purple & OrangeVerified PurchaseMe encantaron, las coloque en mi jardín y le dieron un lindo estilo a mi decoración de halloween
- EmilyReviewed in Canada on September 15, 2022
5.0 out of 5 stars Nice and bright!
Color: Warm WhiteVerified PurchaseI love these lights! I think the value for the money is good. We’ve had crazy rain here since I installed them and they still work perfectly. Fairly lights take awhile to unwind but there’s no getting around that no matter what brand you buy. these are bright and respond quickly to charging. I love them!
EmilyNice and bright!
Reviewed in Canada on September 15, 2022
Images in this review